Greenpeace had been very active in the peace flotilla at Mururoa in 1973. This article summarises Grant Apperley’s official report on the role the Navy had in salvaging the Greenpeace ship Rainbow Warrior and in preserving evidence for the police investigation.
It is reprinted from Navy Today July 2005, when it was written to mark the 20th Anniversary of the sinking of the Rainbow Warrior.
This article also appeared in The White Ensign Issue 05 Winter 2008.
On Thursday 10 July 1985, the British registered Greenpeace vessel, Rainbow Warrior was sunk in Auckland Harbour by French saboteurs of the DGSE (General Directorate for External Security).
Greenpeace photographer Fernando Pereira was killed when the limpet mines exploded.
The Navy’s initial response was just 2 hours after the explosions, when Leading Diver (LDR) Schmidt of the Operational Diving Team (OPT) entered the wreck and discovered Pereria’s body. The Diving Team also conducted a search of the hull and wharf for any other explosives; none were found.
The police declared the wreck a crime scene; they wanted it recovered for forensic examinaiton, they also wanted to examine the seabed under the ship.
Beginning the following Monday the ODT, under the command of LT Hugh Aitken conducted a survey of the wreck, reporting a huge hole in the engine room, and extensive damage around the propeller and propeller shaft. In the subsequent two weeks the naval dockyard team assessed various options for salvage, while the Divers began clearing the interior of the ship, moving some 30 tons of equipment and fittings out of the wreck.
The salvage task was a daunting one; Rainbow Warrior had sunk onto hr starboard side, burying the huge (2.4 x 1.5m) hole in the hull in the soft mud of the seabed. But the impact of the two limpet mines was immense, shock blast and shrapnel damage had spread far into the ship.
When eventually salvaged a full inspection revealed she could never be made seaworthy again.
Many preparations went on in the next two weeks, before the Master of the Rainbow Warrior signed a salvage agreement with the police on 24 July; the next day CDRE Tempero (Commodore Auckland) signed an Administration Order placing Gavin Apperley, Constructive Manager at HMNZ Dockyard, in charge of the salvage. The Navy’s resources, including the ODT were placed in support of Apperley’s team; the Ministry of Transport’s Oil Pollution Unit was also available (led by Gerry Wright, a former naval officer).
LTCDR Brian Ward, then Assistant Queen’s Harbour Master and in charge of the Support Team of Philomel sailors, saw the salvage in three main phases.
Even though the trawler had been sunk in shallow water and next to a wharf, the salvage was not simple. First there were structural limitations of the wharf itself. The there were the structural limitations of the ship.
Rainbow Warrior was old, suffered corrosion in key decks and bulkheads and had been rather carelessly converted by Greenpeace so that few of her internal bulkheads were in fact watertight (because cable runs and other alterations had been made without regard for basic ship fitting).
The salvage effort began with the divers; they had to clear the interior, black shrapnel holes and cable runs, and guide the suction hoses to rid the hull of the mud; even the ship’s drawings had to be recovered from underwater.And, all this had to be done with police evidence in mind. It was of course winter; the days were short, the water cold – and polluted with diesel from the bomb-damaged fuel tanks – while the wind would blow up a nasty chop that pounded into the basin beside Marsden Wharf.
But after several approaches. It became inevitable that the Dockyard would have to fabricate a patch to cover the main hole in the engine room, and the divers would have to attach ti to the hole. But because the ship could not be moved, the patch would have to be applied with the ship still on her side and barely a foot of clearance for the divers to operate in.
Underlying each of the decisions were many hours of calculations by the Constructor and his team. For all its size and apparent strength a ship is a dynamic object, but when filled with a 1000 tons of water and weakened by shock or blast, the structure can easily buckle or collapse.The Dockyard team knew that a wrong move could break up the ship, or worse an error could cause casualties among the salvage team. The Dockyard staff were assisted by the Ministry of Transport, who made their Apple III computer (in Wellington) available to assist with calculations.
For the divers it was continuous hard work. Lt Aitken reported that, “The salvage was a challenging task, conducted in conditions of nil visibility and offten involving a high degree of difficulty.”
The Divers used surface supply breathing apparatus, which meant they had a continuous supply air supply. In the relatively shallow depths, they didn’t have to worry about decompression tables, and the SSBA meant they enjoyed hard-wired communications with the surface.
They quickly developed an excellent working relationship with the Police, Auckland Harbour Board and the Fire Brigade (who provided additional pumps to assist the salvage).
Early on the decision was made to hire salvage airbags from Salvage Pacific Ltd in Fiji, these bags each with a five ton lift capacity were mounted along Rainbow Warrior’s starboard side to give additional buoyancy and to control the lift . That meant more work for the ODT who had to bolt and weld on the steel eyepieces to fasten each airbag to the hull of the ship.
In addition, the Ministry of Transport loaned Captain G.C.Wright to assist and oversee the large capacity MOT pumps. “Always helpful , always cheerful, Captain Wright became a strong member of our team,” LTCDR Ward reported.
LTCDR Ward’s support team did all the surface tasks imaginable; working on and in the Rainbow Warrior to make the accessible structure watertight, operating the pumps , even cooking for the whole salvage team. Few across the harbour in Philomel understood the adverse conditions they were working in . For example the supply of dry socks became a bone of contention when the Supply Depot not understanding the nature of salvage work, told the salvage crew to wash and dry their own socks.
In mid-August, as more of the ship was being p[umped out and made watertight it became apparent that the Navy’s Rover gas turbine pumps were not up to the task.The Fire Brigade supplemented the pumping effort at short notice, in time for the final lift. When the final lift took place it was a cacophony of diesel engines; the five big MOT salvage pumps, five more from the Harbour Board and even the scream from the two Rovers, and the roar of air compressors supplying the divers and filling the salvage airbags.
At 0245 on 21 August the final lift began. By dawn Rainbow Warrior was partially afloat and almost upright, she was moved south and the pumps rearranged for the harbour crossing. At 1245 on 22 August Rainbow Warrior was docked in Calliope Dock, as water drained down the full extent of the bomb blast could be seen,
A Royal Navy underwater explosives expert flew in to assist with the police examination; finally the Dockyard was tasked with sealing the ship and making her watertight for eventual disposal. On 25 September the Rainbow Warrior was undocked and the Navy’s part in her salvage came to an end.
Today the Rainbow Warrior lies in Matauri Bay, Northland, accessible to sports dievrs. Her salvage was an interdepartmental and commerical team effort led by the Naval Dockyard and involving many from HMNZS PhILOMEL.
The salvage of the Rainbow Warrior is an event the New Zealand Navy can look back on with pride.
G.C. Apperley, Salvage of the Rainbow Warrior: July/August 1985 at Marsden Wharf East, Report from Constructive Manager, HMNZ Dockyard, Auckland: RNZN., 1985.